Buy the Physicians Formula Super CC+ Cream Color-Correction +.

One of these is a real product with thousands of happy faces behind it, the other is a server error, and that is not a real contest.

What was compared

1. You can actually purchase this one
The other listing is a 503 Service Unavailable error page, not a product, it has no price, no ingredients, no photos, nothing to click buy on. The CC Cream is in stock at $16.99 and ships. That alone ends the debate.
2. 6,898 people rated it, zero rated the error
The CC Cream carries 6,898 ratings averaging 4.2 stars and Amazon's Choice status, with reviewers specifically praising natural-looking coverage on dull, uneven skin. There is no possible review history for a server error page.
3. Built for sensitive, acne-prone skin
It is hypoallergenic, oil free and fragrance free, and reviewers with sensitive skin specifically say it does not break them out while still evening out tone better than other CC creams they tried. That is a real, specific use case an error page cannot serve anyone.
4. Lasts most of a year for under $17
At $16.99 per tube, reviewers report it lasting 6 to 9 months of regular use, which is genuinely cheap daily coverage. Compare that to spending money on nothing at all, since the other option has no product behind its price field.
5. Yes, coverage is sheer. Buy it anyway.
Some reviewers note it looks shiny going on and skin can show through since coverage is sheer, not full glam. Unless you need heavy full-coverage foundation for photos or events, that sheer, skin-like finish is exactly what most daily CC cream buyers want, and it still beats a product that does not exist.