Buy the BLACK+DECKER 12-Cup Drip Coffee Maker.
It brews for a whole household, sets itself up the night before, and has 50,000 ratings backing it up, the Elite Gourmet is a dorm-room stopgap wearing a coffee maker's clothes.
What was compared
- BLACK+DECKER 12-Cup Drip Coffee Maker with Vortex Brewing: Home & Kitchen — $31.97
- Elite Gourmet EHC4128 Automatic 4-Cup Drip Coffee Maker, Black | Glass carafe, Pause N Ser... — $15.99
Five reasons
1. One pot lasts the house, not just one mug
BLACK+DECKER brews 12 cups against the Elite Gourmet's 4, and reviews of the Elite flag that as too little for heavy drinkers or bigger households. Unless you're brewing solo in a dorm or RV, that means restarting the Elite two or three times before noon.
2. Coffee is ready before you're even up
BLACK+DECKER's QuickTouch programming and brew strength selector let you set it the night before and pick how strong you want it. The Elite Gourmet is a plain on/off switch with no timer, so every single pot starts and stops by your hand.
3. A track record the Elite hasn't built yet
BLACK+DECKER carries over 50,000 ratings averaging 4.4 stars, a real history of daily use to lean on. The Elite Gourmet's evidence is thinner, including a customer report of the unit breaking completely within months.
4. Yes, it costs 16 dollars more. Buy it anyway.
The Elite Gourmet wins on sticker price at $15.99 against $31.97, no argument there. But that gap buys you triple the capacity, a working timer and a proven track record, spread across years of morning coffee that's not a real cost.
5. A warranty you can actually point to
BLACK+DECKER lists a documented 2-year limited manufacturer warranty. The Elite Gourmet's page only surfaces a paid third-party Allstate protection plan, not confirmed coverage from the maker itself if it fails.
Run your own decision on Pickerooo