Buy the Google Pixel.

A brand new phone with a bigger battery, a second camera lens and a guaranteed update runway beats a used iPhone with extra storage you probably won't fill.

What was compared

  • Google Pixel · $599.00
  • Apple iPhone 17e · $565.69

Five reasons

  1. 1. All day battery that doesn't leave you hunting a charger

    The 10a packs a 5100mAh cell with over 30 hours of typical use, while the 17e's smaller battery runs dry sooner on a heavy day. If you're glued to your phone from breakfast to midnight, that gap is the difference between carrying a charger and not.

  2. 2. Catches the wide shot the 17e simply can't

    The 10a's dual camera system includes an ultrawide lens for group photos and tight spaces, while the 17e ships with a single camera and no ultrawide. Unless you only ever shoot tight portraits, that missing lens shows up on every trip or family gathering.

  3. 3. Seven guaranteed years, not a vague promise

    Google commits to 7 years of Pixel Drops, security patches and OS upgrades on the 10a, a specific guarantee Apple does not publish for the 17e. That means a phone you can keep running current software years after the iPhone's support quietly ends.

  4. 4. Brand new battery and body, not someone else's wear

    The 10a ships factory new with full warranty and 100 percent battery health from day one. The 17e listed here is Renewed, meaning a previous owner's wear, an already-cycled battery and a shorter runway before it needs replacing.

  5. 5. Yes, it has double the storage. It barely matters.

    The 17e's 256GB beats the 10a's 128GB on paper, and that's real if you shoot hours of 4K video or never delete anything. Everyone else lives in cloud photos and streaming apps, where 128GB covers daily use easily, so you're paying extra for room you'll never fill.

Run your own decision on Pickerooo

Related verdicts

More verdicts in Phones