Buy the Jergens Natural Glow +Firming Self Tanner Lotion Fair.

One of these you can actually buy and use tonight, the other is sitting on a shelf marked out of stock.

What was compared

1. One you can actually order today
Eucerin's own listing says it is currently unavailable and Amazon does not know when it is coming back, while Jergens ships free with Prime tomorrow. A better cream sitting in warehouse limbo helps nobody, it is a placeholder page, not a purchase.
2. A third of the price per ounce
Jergens runs about $1.40 per fluid ounce against roughly $14.82 per fluid ounce for Eucerin's 75ml bottle at $37.06. For a lotion you rub on legs and arms daily, that gap adds up fast over a year of refills.
3. Years of reviews, not a gamble
Jergens Natural Glow has years of consistent reports of natural, buildable color in 3 to 5 days. Eucerin users report the brand recently changed its formula and their skin now reacts badly, a real risk on something you have not tried yet.
4. Built to avoid the orange mistake
One complaint about ruined-looking legs is the exception, not the rule. Jergens uses a low-DHA gradual formula so color builds slowly over days instead of turning orange overnight, and most reviewers describe a natural, streak-free result.
5. Yes, urea creams heal skin. Different job.
Eucerin's 5% urea formula is genuinely proven for severe dryness, eczema and psoriasis, and if that is your actual problem, go buy a urea cream, just not this listing since it cannot even be shipped right now. For daily moisturizing with a gradual tan, Jergens is the one doing the job you came here for.