Buy the Supergoop! PLAY Everyday Lotion SPF 50.

A lotion that only moisturizes is solving half the problem one that protects and moisturizes already solves.

What was compared

1. No SPF means no real protection
Kiehl's Creme de Corps has zero SPF, so it does nothing to block UV rays, while Supergoop's SPF 50 broad spectrum protects daily. Skipping sun protection every day compounds into real skin damage over years, not a small gap.
2. One tube covers your whole face and body
Supergoop is built and labeled for face and body use, so it handles your entire routine. Kiehl's Creme de Corps is a body-only formula, meaning it never replaces what you actually need on your face.
3. Stays put when you sweat or swim
Supergoop PLAY is rated water and sweat resistant for 80 minutes, made for real activity outside. Kiehl's Creme de Corps carries no resistance rating at all, so it is the wrong call for a beach day, a run, or time in the pool.
4. Cheaper for something you reapply constantly
At $28 against $39, Supergoop costs less upfront for a product you are meant to reapply through the day. Sunscreen is a repeat purchase, so the lower price compounds every time you rebuy it, unlike a once-a-day lotion.
5. Yes, Kiehl's feels richer. Buy it anyway.
Kiehl's is genuinely richer on very dry skin, that edge is real. If you need an intensive night moisturizer on top, keep it for that, but for daily wear Supergoop moisturizes plus protects, and skipping SPF to chase extra richness is the wrong trade for most people.